When you’re planning a trip to Florida’s Gulf Coast, finding the right places to eat is just as important as choosing the perfect vacation rental. From fresh seafood to casual bites by the beach, the dining scene on St. George Island is filled with flavor and variety. To help you decide where to go, we’ve rounded up the top 5 restaurants on St George Island that consistently deliver excellent meals and memorable experiences.
Blue Parrot in St George Island
If you ask anyone about dining in the area, the first stop that comes to mind is the Blue Parrot in St George Island. This beachfront restaurant has become a landmark, offering incredible views of the Gulf paired with a wide-ranging menu. Guests can enjoy fresh seafood baskets, burgers, and tropical drinks, all while dining just steps from the sand.
The laid-back environment makes it a favorite for families, while the tiki bar atmosphere appeals to those looking for a fun evening out. With live music often playing and unbeatable sunset views, it’s an island experience you won’t want to miss.
Paddy’s Raw Bar
For those who love oysters, Paddy’s Raw Bar is a must. This open-air spot keeps things casual with a fun and lively ambiance. The menu features local oysters, shrimp, and cold drinks, perfect for a relaxed afternoon or evening.
One of the highlights here is the sense of community. Locals and visitors gather for trivia nights, live music, and friendly service that makes you feel right at home. If you’re looking for authentic things to do in St George Island, enjoying oysters and a cold drink at Paddy’s should be on your list.
Beach Pit
Barbecue and seafood come together at the Beach Pit, a family-owned restaurant that serves up hearty portions in a welcoming setting. Their smoked meats are slow-cooked to perfection, while the seafood dishes highlight fresh local catches.
The Beach Pit is especially popular for breakfast, offering generous portions to start your day. From pancakes to omelets, the menu has something for everyone. If you’re craving comfort food after a long beach day, this is the place to go.
Lynn’s Quality Oysters
Technically located across the bridge in Eastpoint, Lynn’s Quality Oysters is worth the short drive. This seafood market and oyster bar specializes in some of the freshest seafood on the Gulf. Visitors can sample oysters raw, steamed, or baked, and pair them with a cold beer for the perfect coastal meal.
The no-frills atmosphere lets the food speak for itself. Grab a table on the deck overlooking the water and enjoy a meal that highlights the best of the local catch. It’s also a great place to pick up seafood to bring back to your rental for a home-cooked feast.
BJ’s Pizza & Subs
When you’re traveling with family or in the mood for something casual, BJ’s Pizza & Subs is a go-to spot. Known for its hand-tossed pizzas and made-to-order subs, this restaurant delivers reliable comfort food at affordable prices.
Kids love the arcade games and casual atmosphere, making it an easy choice after a busy day at the beach. It’s also one of the best options if you’re ordering takeout for a group. While seafood might be the star on the island, sometimes a slice of pizza is exactly what you’re craving.
Book Your St. George Island Vacation Rental with Southern Coast Vacation Properties
Great dining is just one of the many reasons people love visiting this part of Florida. At Southern Coast Vacation Properties, we make your stay even more enjoyable with thoughtfully curated homes across the island. Whether you’re planning a romantic getaway or traveling with family and friends, our St. George Island vacation rentals provide comfort, convenience, and easy access to everything the island has to offer.
As a woman-owned business, we take pride in offering boutique accommodations across the region, including Forgotten Coast vacation rentals in Cape San Blas, Port St. Joe, Carrabelle, Eastpoint, Miramar Beach, Indian Pass, and Apalachicola. Guests also enjoy the option to rent golf carts and receive credit for premium beach gear rentals, making your stay as effortless as possible.
Our portfolio includes everything from cozy cottages to spacious homes, so you’ll always find a property that fits your needs. By booking with us, you get more than a rental. You get personalized service and access to the very best of the Forgotten Coast. Pair your stay with delicious meals from these local restaurants, and your trip to St. George Island will be unforgettable.